- 24 of 50 MSPs were recommended by at least one AI tool in two of three runs.
- Gemini and Google's AI Overview mostly named firms Google already ranks. ChatGPT didn't.
- Recommended firms had better websites: 35 out of 70 on our website score, against 27 for the rest.
What we found
Buyers are starting to ask AI for a shortlist: "who's the best IT support company in Leeds?" We asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Google's AI Overview six questions like that in each of 10 UK towns, three times each, and checked whether the 50 MSPs in our study were named.
20 never came up at all, and 6 more were named only once. Many of the firms AI did name weren't in our sample at all: larger regional firms and the businesses listed most prominently on directories.
| AI tool | Firms named (of 50) | Firms that rank on Google (of 25) | Firms that don't (of 25) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gemini | 16 | 12 | 4 |
| ChatGPT | 15 | 8 | 7 |
| Google AI Overview | 8 | 7 | 1 |
“AI answers change from one run to the next, so don't chase a single result. Make your website clear about who you serve, where you work and how fast you respond, keep your directory listings accurate, and check what AI says about you every month.”
Google's AI follows Google. ChatGPT doesn't.
Half our firms rank on Google's first page for IT support in their town and half don't. Gemini named 12 of the 25 that rank, against 4 of the 25 that don't. Google's AI Overview named 7 against 1. Both draw on Google search, so that's what you'd expect.
ChatGPT was different: 8 against 7. Ranking on Google made no clear difference to whether ChatGPT recommended a firm.
Google's AI Overview often didn't answer at all: 81 of its 180 searches showed no AI Overview.
What the recommended firms have in common
The clearest difference is the website itself. Firms an AI tool recommended score 35 out of 70 on our website score, against 27 for the rest, and the gap holds among firms that don't rank on Google. Their sites say more plainly who they serve, show more proof and make it easier to get in touch.
| What AI answers mention | Answers (of 360) | MSP sites that show it (of 48) |
|---|---|---|
| Microsoft | 336 | 34 show a vendor partnership |
| Cyber Essentials | 335 | 26 |
| Response times | 330 | 19 give a specific time |
| Being local | 325 | not measured |
| ISO certification | 281 | 9 show ISO 27001 |
AI answers lean on exactly what buyers ask about. Firms showing Cyber Essentials were named more often (17 of 26, against 6 of 22), but much of that gap goes once you allow for Google visibility, so treat it as a signal, not a shortcut.
Where AI gets its answers
AI tools lean heavily on directories. ChatGPT's most-cited source was whatmsp.co.uk, in 45 of its 180 answers, then clutch.co in 34. Gemini cited cloudtango.net in 91 of 180, then threebestrated.co.uk in 51. Being listed, and listed well, on the directories AI reads is part of being recommended.
The answers keep changing
Ask the same question three times and you get different firms. 4 times in 10 that one of our firms was named, it didn't come up again in the other two runs. ChatGPT and Gemini cited the same sources only about a third of the time from one run to the next.
When we asked about each firm by name, the AI tools described 30 of 49 correctly, 17 partly and 2 wrongly.
What to do about it
- State the basics where AI can read them. Your towns, the size of client you serve, your response times, Cyber Essentials and vendor partnerships, in plain text on your site.
- Get listed on the directories AI cites. Check your entries on the directories named above and keep them current.
- Check what AI says about you every month. One answer is a snapshot; the trend is what matters.
17 of 48 sites publish an llms.txt file, and we found no clear link between having one and being recommended.
About the data
From the MSP Website Benchmark: 50 managed IT firms in 10 UK towns, half visible on Google and half not, chosen at random and checked on 227 data points on 9 November 2026. Website counts are out of 48, because two sites couldn't be read.
Questions
Does ChatGPT recommend local IT support companies?
Yes, when asked for one in a town. In our study it named 15 of the 50 firms in at least two of three runs, and whether a firm ranked on Google made no clear difference.
How do I get my MSP recommended by ChatGPT?
There's no switch to flip. In our study, the firms AI recommended had clearer, better-proven websites, and the answers drew heavily on directories. Work on both.
Is ranking on Google enough?
For Gemini and Google's AI Overview it helps a lot. For ChatGPT, ranking made no clear difference.
Thirteen years in web, search and growth, from running a small firm’s marketing single-handed to leading web teams at B2B software companies. Michael shapes what NetNav checks and how it explains what it finds, writes many of its guides, and leads NetNav Research, our studies of how real business websites perform.